While Peel had presented Top Of The Pops in the 1960s, and appeared as a "member" of the Faces in 1971, his main stint with the show was during the 1980s. Peel made a total of 49 appearances between 1968 and 1995. The chronological list below was drawn up from the BBC online archive listing of the programme's presenters. This covers only shows that still exist in the BBC archives and may not be complete in all cases. Dates given are for Thursday broadcasts and not when the show was recorded (usually Tuesday the same week).
1968
- Co-presenter: Jimmy Savile
1981
- Co-presenters: Andy Peebles, Paul Burnett, Paul Gambaccini, Dave Lee Travis, Adrian Juste, Simon Bates, David Jensen, Tony Blackburn, Steve Wright, Peter Powell, Jimmy Savile, Richard Skinner, Mike Read
1982
- Co-presenters: none
- Co-presenters: none
- Co-presenters: Debbie Harry (special guest co-host)
- Co-presenters: none
- Co-presenters: none
- Co-presenters: Annie Nightingale, Dave Lee Travis, Andy Peebles, Mike Read, David Jensen, Tony Blackburn, Jonathan King, Jimmy Savile, Mike Smith, Paul Burnett, Steve Wright, Adrian Juste, Paul Gambaccini, Tommy Vance, Alexis Korner, Richard Skinner, Peter Powell, Adrian John
- Co-presenters: none
- Co-presenters: none
- Co-presenters: Dave Lee Travis, Peter Powell, Mike Read, Andy Peebles, Steve Wright, Tommy Vance, Mike Smith, Richard Skinner, Jimmy Savile, Janice Long
1983
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenters: Dave Lee Travis, Steve Wright, Gary Davies, Mike Smith, Paul Gambaccini, Peter Powell, Simon Bates, Tommy Vance, Richard Skinner, David Jacobs, Mike Read, Tony Blackburn, Noel Edmonds, David Jensen, Andy Peebles, Janice Long, Jimmy Savile, Pat Sharp
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Presented by Simon Bates and Peter Powell, with Peel presenting the European Chart section of the show.
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: Mike Smith
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
1984
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: David Jensen
- Co-presenter: Tommy Vance
- Co-presenter: Richard Skinner
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
- Co-presenter: Tommy Vance
Note: Peel and Jensen were also scheduled to present the show on 1984-04-05 but it didn't go out because of a strike. [1]
1985
- Co-presenter: Richard Skinner
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
- Co-presenters: Janice Long, Dixie Peach, Steve Wright, Gary Davies, Jonathan King
1986
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
1987
- Co-presenter: Janice Long
1995
14 December 1995 (TOTP) - Peel presented with This Is Your Life big red book at the end of show.
- Co-presenter: none
